Independent political journalismGlobal · Evidence-led · Argument-driven
STATE & POWER
Politics, power and the arguments shaping the world
asia · Analysis

China Wants to Write the Rules of a Multipolar Security Order. Its Neighbours Still Fear the Fine Print

The Xiangshan Forum gives Beijing a platform to sell cooperation and multipolarity while disputes over Taiwan and the South China Sea keep trust in short supply.

Map of Asia
Image: Wikimedia Commons contributors · Regional fallback

China's preferred language for global security is increasingly polished: multipolarity, cooperation, shared development and resistance to bloc confrontation. The difficulty is that several of its neighbours hear those words while watching military pressure closer to home.

What happened

Reuters reported that China's Xiangshan Forum is opening amid tensions over Taiwan, the South China Sea and uncertainty about US commitments in Asia.

The argument

A state cannot build a convincing alternative security order through rhetoric alone. Regional leadership depends on whether smaller countries believe rules will constrain the strong as well as the weak.

Why this matters beyond the headline

The Xiangshan Forum gives Beijing a platform to sell cooperation and multipolarity while disputes over Taiwan and the South China Sea keep trust in short supply. The issue reaches beyond one news cycle because security increasingly joins semiconductors, energy, trade and technological sovereignty.

governments want resilience without surrendering cross-border prosperity. State & Power therefore treats the story as part of a wider political system rather than an isolated event.

investment, procurement and alliance behaviour reveal where power is moving. Watch legislation, budgets, courts, polling, investment and implementation rather than declarations of victory.

The strongest counterargument

US alliances and military deployments also shape regional insecurity, and Beijing can reasonably argue that an Asian security system permanently centred on American primacy is not neutral.

What happens next

The strongest signal from the forum will be whether Chinese officials address concrete mechanisms for crisis management rather than simply contrasting multipolarity with US-led alliances.

Editorial note

This article separates sourced reporting from analysis. The factual record is linked below; judgments and conclusions are State & Power's editorial analysis.

China Wants to Write the Rules of a Multipolar Security Order. Its Neighbours Still Fear the Fine Print | State & Power